Peppermint Temple Rub Study: Where Camphor Fits In

Temple rubs have a famous study behind them, and the surprise is that it is about peppermint. Camphor often gets credit for the habit, so it is worth knowing what the trial really tested and why camphor's cool feeling is a separate story.

Camphor Essential Oil

Our own Camphor Essential Oil, in sizes from 0.5 oz to bulk.

From $9.99

Shop Now →

The trial behind the habit

In 1996, Göbel and colleagues published a randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind crossover study in Der Nervenarzt. It covered 164 headache attacks in 41 adults with tension-type headache. The test preparation was 10% peppermint oil in 90% ethanol, spread across the forehead and temples and repeated after 15 and 30 minutes, and it was compared with 1,000 mg of oral acetaminophen and with placebo. Both peppermint oil and acetaminophen did better than placebo, with no significant difference between them, and no adverse events were reported.

It is a carefully built study, and it is also narrow. Forty-one people is small, the preparation was a specific peppermint-in-ethanol solution, and the condition was one defined type of headache. Nothing in it involves camphor. Carrying the result over to a different oil, a different strength and a different carrier would be a leap the authors did not make.

Why the story sticks

Temple rubs feel intuitive. A cool stripe across the forehead, the smell of a medicine cabinet, a minute spent sitting still: it is easy to see why the habit passes down through families. Rituals like that are powerful in their own right, and we enjoy them. What we like less is when a ritual borrows the authority of a study that was about something else.

Where camphor does connect

There is a genuine link, and it is about sensation. A 2013 paper in Chemical Senses by Selescu and colleagues showed that camphor activates TRPM8, the cold- and menthol-sensitive channel, in cells and in rat sensory neurons, and that it also dampens the channel's response to menthol. Camphor and menthol-type compounds share a target, which is why both feel cool on skin. That tells us why a camphor rub feels the way it does. It does not tell us what a rub does for a headache.

If you enjoy comparing the personalities of these two oils, we do that in camphor versus peppermint oil, and our overview of camphor oil shows how the evidence for camphor looks overall.

If you love the scent, not the claim

Camphor oil's aroma is sharp, cooling and crystalline with a dry woody base, and it is a top note, so it arrives fast and fades fast. As a scent it is a pleasure of its own, with no study needed. Put one drop on a paper strip, hold it at arm's length, take one short sniff and see what it brings to mind. Then try a second strip beside it with lavender or a little orange peel, and notice how camphor oil sharpens its neighbour.

That is the use we would point you to: a seasoning in a blend, a drop at a time, in a room with adults only.

Near the eyes

Temples sit close to the eyes, and hands, sweat and drips travel. That is a good reason to keep camphor oil away from that area entirely. It is also strong enough that we recommend diluting to 0.5% to 2% in a carrier before any skin contact, with a patch test first. If anything gets in the eyes, call Poison Help at 1-800-222-1222 or a clinician for guidance. Camphor and children are a poor mix, as our children's page explains, and anyone who is pregnant or nursing should ask an OB-GYN or midwife first; see our pregnancy page.

How to read the next headline

Whenever a study is passed around online, three questions do most of the work. What exactly was tested: which oil, at what strength, in what carrier? Who took part, and how many of them? Was there a comparison group? These are the questions we ask about every study we mention, and the peppermint trial answers them well.

A claim that cannot answer them has not earned its place in a routine, however warm the story around it.

When a headache needs a clinician

Headaches vary a lot in cause and seriousness, and sorting them out is a physician's job. Frequent, worsening or unusual headaches deserve an appointment, and a sudden severe one, or one with fever, a stiff neck, confusion, weakness or vision changes, calls for urgent care. We sell an external cosmetic oil and nothing here is advice for a headache.

What we like about the peppermint trial is how it models good thinking: a defined preparation, a defined group, a defined condition. That is the standard we would hold any oil to, ours included.